aftershave balm vs aftershave lotion vs cologne

What Is The Best Men's After Shave: Balm vs Lotion vs Cologne

Shaving doesn't have to be a painful chore - it can actually be an enjoyable ritual.

But we get it, after shaving, your skin can feel like it's on fire. It's dry, sensitive, and inflamed, and that's why aftershave is crucial.

But hold up, don't just grab any ol' product off the shelf!

Aftershave lotion, aftershave balm, and cologne are all different things, and using the wrong one can cause more harm than good.

In this article, we'll help you navigate the world of post-shave products, so you can soothe, cool, and moisturize your skin like a pro.

What Is Aftershave Lotion Used For?

Aftershave lotion, sometimes just referred to as aftershave, is scented and often alcohol-based. It calms shaving irritation and disinfects any small nicks you might have given yourself along the way.

True, alcohol can get rid of bacteria on your skin, but the problem is, it can also worsen irritation, dry your skin out, and cause it to flake. 

Some men like their aftershave lotions to be scented because it means they don't have to use a cologne afterward, but it can oftentimes leave skin red, dry, and irritated all morning. 

What Does Aftershave Balm Do?

Aftershave balm serves the same primary purpose as aftershave lotion: to soothe your skin after shaving.

However, unlike aftershave lotion, balm generally does not contain alcohol and is designed to moisturize your freshly shaved skin. As a result, it usually's thicker and creamier in consistency than aftershave lotion.

A typical aftershave balm has a light scent derived primarily from its key ingredients.

Many men find it is much kinder to post-shaved skin than its alcohol-based counterpart.

You'll know if the product you're using contains alcohol because that's what gives you that 'stinging' sensation post-shave.

Is Cologne An Aftershave Product?

According to the master perfumer, Roja Dove: 

"Aftershave was a fragrant alcohol rub that men would pat onto their cheeks and neck after a shave, so why it is still used to simply spritz onto the neck and wrists is beyond me."

Cologne is a term used to describe a fragrance with a very weak concentration of scent, but it's still a fragrance at its core—and definitely not aftershave.

Even more, it doesn't contain the necessary properties to hydrate and soothe your skin after shaving. Because most colognes are alcohol-based, you expose yourself to burning skin and possible irritation around post-shave cuts.

What Ingredients Are Bad In Aftershave?


Many aftershaves contain isopropyl alcohol or ethyl alcohol, similar to what you might find in a hand sanitizer or household cleaner.

These ingredients are great for killing bacteria or toxins on your face but not so great when it comes to soothing your skin post-shave (as you can probably tell by that burning sensation you get after shaving). 

This is why it's crucial to look at the ingredients in a product and make sure you don't take something that will harm you.

Alcohol comes in many forms but can typically be found in an ingredient list as:

  • Methanol
  • Denatured alcohol
  • Ethanol
  • Isopropyl alcohol
  • SD alcohol
  • Ethyl alcohol

A great natural alternative to alcohol is Witch Hazel. Naturally astringent, antiseptic, and cooling, Witch Hazel Water is an excellent cleanser, tonic, and toner for the skin. It also aids in the cleansing of the skin's pores and helps stimulate the skin.


Phthalates are chemicals used to soften plastics and—believe it or not—are often used in some shaving products to soften your skin, too.

Some research has also shown that phthalates can reduce sperm count, so don't take that risk and make sure you rid of any products containing it from your bathroom.

Phthalates can be found in an ingredient list as:

  • DEHP (di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate)
  • DNOP (di-n-octyl phthalate)
  • DMP (dimethyl phthalate)
  • BBP (benzyl butyl phthalate)
  • DBP (dibutyl phthalate)
  • DINP (diisononyl phthalate)
  • DEP (diethyl phthalate)
  • DIDP (diisodecyl phthalate)


The problem with "fragrance" in an ingredients list is that it can mean almost anything that adds a scent to a product. In essence, it's an umbrella term for a multitude of possibly toxic and irritating ingredients.

When in doubt, always opt for an aftershave containing a fragrance derived from natural ingredients (like essential oils) or go completely fragrance-free, if you prefer.

Fragrance can be found in the ingredients list as:

  • Fragrance
  • Parfum

Best After Shave Balm for sensitive skin

Look for a balm containing soothing natural ingredients since one of the significant problems post-shave is redness and irritation.

An aftershave balm that adequately moisturizes your skin will go a long way. 

It would be best if you also looked for a non-greasy formula and an aftershave balm that's pH balanced so you don't upset your skin's natural chemistry.

What Ingredients Make A Good Aftershave?

Be on the lookout for these natural ingredients:

Vitamin E 

It protects your freshly shaved skin from breakdown caused by environmental damage, like pollution and cigarette smoke.

Vitamin E is considered an antioxidant superhero, known for its ability to hydrate post-shave skin and calm irritation deeply.

Aloe vera leaf juice

Also known as Aloe Barbadensis, aloe vera leaf juice's nourishing properties promote minor wound, burn, and rash healing and is also an excellent moisturizer and emollient. It is often used as a skin and hair soother, healer, and repairer, as well as a natural collagen booster.

White tea leaf extract 

White tea is a lightly oxidized tea. Studies have shown that white tea has an anti-inflammatory effect on the skin and can strengthen and protect the skin matrix.

Its rejuvenating impact sets it apart from other tea-based skincare agents because white 

tea can provide partial protection from UV damage caused by the sun.

Witch hazel

It's a great natural alternative to alcohol. Witch hazel has all the antibacterial advantages of alcohol but is non-irritating and won't dry your skin out. 


Allantoin's anti-inflammatory, healing, calming, and nourishing properties make it a perfect ingredient for stimulating healthy skin cell growth.

Chamomile flower extract 

Chamomile flower extract has soothing, healing, and anti-inflammatory properties to help calm and cool sensitive skin.


Menthol is a natural cooling astringent used in many products for the skin, scalp, and body.

Click here for a full list of the best natural ingredients found in men's skincare products.


Now that you know the difference between an aftershave balm, aftershave lotion, and cologne, we believe you'll make the right decision for yourself.

Make sure to pay special attention to the ingredients since they make the biggest difference in the post-shave experience you'll have. 

An excellent example of a natural, alcohol-free product is our men's aftershave balm, which soothes, calms, and hydrates your face to prevent itchy rashes and blemishes. 

The end result is post-shave skin that is cool, smooth, and refreshed.

Back to blog

Claim Your Free Skincare Kit Worth $60!

No catch, no sample sizes — get full-size products straight to your door. Just cover shipping.

Join our VITAMAN Tribe to claim your kit:


    Packed with the highest levels of Vitamin C in the world. Contains powerful antioxidants that combat premature aging. 

    OzC SERUM 

    Rich in natural phenols. Protects against pollution damage and helps boost collagen production levels, making the skin firmer.


    This treatment for male pattern baldness is shown to prevent the conversion of testosterone into DHT, a leading cause of hair loss.


    This native Australian peach is rich in Vitamin C and packed with essential fatty acids that nourish and protect your hair and scalp.

1 of 4

Meet The founder

Clare Castles, a seasoned beauty therapist, international skincare lecturer, and former salon owner, foresaw the rise of men’s grooming trends in Australia before they took the world by storm.

With an eye for innovation and a heart for creation, Clare embarked on a journey of discovery into indigenous biochemistry, which soon blossomed into a passion for formulating exceptional skincare products.

This unique blend of expertise and enthusiasm led to the birth of VITAMAN in December 1999, marking the dawn of Australia's first true pioneer in men’s grooming.

To this day, Clare remains dedicated to VITAMAN's legacy of being the most innovative, effective, and natural men’s haircare and skincare product range available today.